Instax Pal 2 vs Kodak Charmera: Is It Worth the Extra?
PublishedIf you buy through an affiliate link in this article, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
The quick answer
For most people choosing between the Fujifilm Instax Pal 2 and Kodak Charmera, I would get the Charmera. The Pal 2 gave me sharper photos, autofocus and a much more interesting shooting experience, but I found it hard to justify roughly five times the price for a tiny camera I mainly wanted for fun.
When I filmed this comparison, the Charmera was around $35 and the Pal 2 was around $170. Those are the prices behind my verdict, not a promise about current offers. If you love the Pal 2's design and the price is comfortable for you, I did enjoy using it.
Watch the full video
Watch the full video on YouTube.
Instax Pal 2 vs Kodak Charmera: the useful differences
| Difference | Kodak Charmera | Instax Pal 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Price discussed in my video | About $35 | About $170 |
| Photo output | About 1.6MP | 10MP or lower-resolution 1MP mode |
| Lens and focus | 35mm-equivalent view, fixed focus | Wider 28mm-equivalent view, autofocus |
| Size and handling | About 30g; genuinely keychain sized | About 87g; larger, but still easily pocketable |
| Screen | Small rear screen | Top-mounted screen plus rear viewfinder |
| Photo transfer | USB-C cable or microSD card reader | Phone app with Bluetooth or USB-C connection |
| Storage | Requires a microSD card | Internal memory plus microSD; 100 shots before app connection |
| Video | Low-resolution video with audio at 30fps | No conventional video recording; ten-frame instax Animation feature |
The Pal 2's official specifications and Fujifilm's FAQ clarify the storage behavior discussed below.
The Charmera feels like a keychain camera
The Charmera is small enough that it still surprises me there is a working camera inside it. Its controls are basic: a few buttons, a little rear screen and very little to adjust. I do not expect a serious camera experience from it, which is part of why the low price makes sense to me.
The Pal 2 is bigger in pretty much every direction. It is still a very small camera, but I think of it more as a miniature regular camera than something I would casually add to my keys. Both bodies are plastic, although the Pal 2's plastic felt a little nicer in my hands.
If you want more of my experience with the smaller camera, read my Kodak Charmera review.
The Pal 2 is more enjoyable to operate
The Pal 2's lever and joystick make navigating its menus and changing shooting options easier. The top-mounted screen is my favorite part. I liked looking down at it for waist-level shots and using a different perspective from the usual camera held in front of my face.
It also has a rear viewfinder and a tripod thread. The whole design looks like a tiny vintage camera, and I can see that being the reason someone chooses it. These are useful physical controls, but I would not describe it as a full manual-exposure camera.
I was much less enthusiastic about the projecting male USB-C connector. Plugging the camera into a phone felt awkward, and I could feel flex while holding that setup. An extension cable is included, but I still did not like the arrangement. I did not break the connector; this is a complaint about how it felt to use.
I used the phone app to transfer photos, which was convenient. It also lets you choose the effects loaded onto the camera, with up to six available on the camera at a time. The Charmera has no equivalent app connection, although moving its files with a cable or card reader is straightforward.
The 100-photo limit needs a clarification
In the video, I described having to import and delete the Pal 2's photos after 100 shots, even with a memory card installed. The more precise distinction is 100 shots before connecting to the app, rather than a total storage capacity of 100 photos on any card.
Fujifilm lists approximately 100 images in internal memory, and around 400 images per gigabyte on a microSD card in 10MP mode. Its FAQ also documents a Keep After Transfer setting, so deleting the camera's files after transferring is not compulsory.
To keep them, connect the camera to the app, open settings, select Automatically Delete Data from Camera After Transfer, then choose Keep After Transfer. That corrects the deletion claim in my video. A larger card still does not remove Fujifilm's stated limit on shooting before app connection, so I would account for that workflow before buying one.
The Pal 2 takes better photos, but value is a different question
The Charmera's photos look rough, pixelated and muddy, even in daylight. At night they get worse. It has a fixed-focus lens, so I am not choosing what to focus on in the way I can with a camera that has autofocus.
That does not stop me enjoying it. I can get interesting little photos from the Charmera as long as I want that deliberately low-quality look and keep my expectations realistic.
The Pal 2 produced noticeably sharper, higher-quality photos in my comparison, especially in daylight. Its autofocus is useful for closer subjects, and its wider lens changes what fits into the frame. I also liked being able to switch between the higher-resolution 10MP mode and the rougher 1MP option.
Even with that improvement, both cameras still gave me a nostalgic, low-fi kind of result. For the way I use them, the Pal 2's better files did not make its price feel nearly five times as worthwhile. If the point is a fun little camera with imperfect photos, the cheaper option gets me most of what I want.
The cheaper camera records video
The Charmera records low-quality video and audio at 30fps. It is much the same story as its still photos: technically limited, but something you can have fun with.
The Pal 2 does not record conventional video. Fujifilm does offer instax Animation, which combines ten still frames into a flipbook-style animation, but I would not buy it expecting a normal video mode. That missing option is a real consideration when the cheaper camera includes one.
What I would consider instead at this budget
If I wanted a more useful everyday compact, I would compare the Kodak PIXPRO FZ55. It is larger than either of these tiny cameras, but still pocketable, and I preferred its versatility: a real optical zoom range, a larger screen and a xenon flash.
For learning photography, I also showed a used Canon Rebel XS with an 18-55mm lens. In the video I estimated about $50 for the body and another $40 to $50 for the lens. That is a historical used-price example, and condition and included accessories affect the complete cost. It is much larger than the Pal 2, but it gives you interchangeable lenses and room to learn. The XS does not record video, so this is a still-photography alternative. My Rebel XS review covers its limits.
Frequently asked questions
Does the Instax Pal 2 print photos?
No. The camera captures digital photos. Printing requires a separate compatible Instax printer or hybrid camera, so the Pal 2 alone is not a replacement for an instant camera that produces a print.
Is the Instax Pal 2 sharper than the Charmera?
Yes, in my side-by-side use it produced sharper, higher-quality photos, especially in daylight. I still preferred the Charmera's value for casual low-fi shooting at the prices in my video.
Which one would I buy?
I would pick the Charmera most of the time for a genuinely tiny camera that takes fun, rough-looking photos. You can check the Kodak Charmera single blind box; a blind box does not guarantee a particular design, and check whether the package includes a memory card.
The Pal 2 makes more sense if you specifically want its design, top-down screen and more involved shooting experience, and the extra cost is not a big deal to you. I had fun with it. I just would not spend the extra money expecting the best general-purpose camera for that budget.
For more hands-on camera experiments and comparisons, visit FoxTailWhipz on YouTube.